4.4 Excellent Based on 37 Reviews

Reserve Online

New York Pasta Garden

Our Pick: Top Rated ($30 and under)

1075 Duval St, Key West (Map)

Seafood

lExcellent

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

3910 Reviews

v0.9 miles from Coffee Butler Amphitheater ( 6 mins )

t19 mins walking

Reserve

4.8 Exceptional Based on 209 Reviews

Reserve Online

La Te Da

1125 Duval Street, Key West (Map)

American

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

1328 Reviews

v1.1 miles from Coffee Butler Amphitheater ( 6 mins )

Reserve

4.7 Wonderful Based on 33 Reviews

Reserve Online

Pepe's Cafe

806 Caroline St, Key West (Map)

Steakhouse

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

3183 Reviews

v1.2 miles from Coffee Butler Amphitheater ( 8 mins )

Reserve

4.8 Exceptional Based on 129 Reviews

Reserve Online

Bel Mare

700 Front St, Key West (Map)

Italian

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $51 and over

99 Reviews

v1.2 miles from Coffee Butler Amphitheater ( 8 mins )

Reserve

4.5 Wonderful Based on 78 Reviews

Reserve Online

Alonzo's Oyster Bar

700 Front St 105, Key West (Map)

Seafood

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

2748 Reviews

v1.2 miles from Coffee Butler Amphitheater ( 8 mins )

Reserve

4.7 Wonderful Based on 368 Reviews

Reserve Online

A&B Lobster House

700 Front Street, Key West (Map)

Seafood

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $51 and over

2414 Reviews

v1.2 miles from Coffee Butler Amphitheater ( 8 mins )

Reserve

4.3 Excellent Based on 39 Reviews

Reserve Online

Southernmost Beach Cafe

1405 Duval St, Key West (Map)

Caribbean

lExcellent

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

5955 Reviews

v1.3 miles from Coffee Butler Amphitheater ( 8 mins )

Reserve

4.6 Wonderful Based on 92 Reviews

Reserve Online

Azur

425 Grinnell Street, Key West (Map)

Mediterranean

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $30 and under

1610 Reviews

v1.3 miles from Coffee Butler Amphitheater ( 8 mins )

Reserve

4.6 Wonderful Based on 178 Reviews

Reserve Online

Seven Fish

921 Truman Ave, Key West (Map)

Seafood

lWonderful

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

2372 Reviews

v1.3 miles from Coffee Butler Amphitheater ( 7 mins )

Reserve

4.8 Exceptional Based on 124 Reviews

Reserve Online

Milagro Restaurant and Bar

1401 Simonton St., Key West (Map)

American

lExceptional

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

129 Reviews

v1.4 miles from Coffee Butler Amphitheater ( 8 mins )

Reserve

4.4 Excellent Based on 102 Reviews

Reserve Online

Four Marlins - The Reach Key West

1435 Simonton Street, Key West (Map)

Seafood

lExcellent

Avg Price:Average Price: $31 to $50

v1.4 miles from Coffee Butler Amphitheater ( 8 mins )

Reserve