Menu
| / Venues / New York State Venues
1-12 of 28 Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor Hotels
i List9 Map
4.0 Very Good Based on 410 Reviews
$$$$$ Show Prices
Hotels near Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor - Sound View Greenport

Sound View Greenport

58775 County Rd 48, Greenport (Map)
- (888) 420-1641 (888) 420-1641
eeee 
lVery Good
4.0 of 5 stars1343 Reviews
v11.4 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 73 mins )
Show Prices
4.7 Wonderful Based on 243 Reviews
$$$$$ Show Prices
Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor Hotels - The Menhaden Hotel

The Menhaden Hotel

Our Pick: Top for Nearby Dining
207 Front Street, Greenport (Map)
- (888) 420-1645 (888) 420-1645
eeef 
lWonderful
5.0 of 5 stars279 Reviews
v9.3 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 68 mins )
Show Prices
4.0 Very Good Based on 449 Reviews
$$$$$ Show Prices
Hamlet Inn

Hamlet Inn

Our Pick: Top Rated (Budget)
300 Montauk Highway, Southampton (Map)
- (888) 416-0458 (888) 416-0458
ee 
lVery Good
4.0 of 5 stars109 Reviews
v14.8 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 28 mins )
Show Prices
3.9 Good Based on 34 Reviews
$$$$$ Show Prices
Topping Rose House

Topping Rose House

1 Bridgehampton Sag Harbor Turnpike, Sag Harbor (Map)
- (888) 420-1644 (888) 420-1644
eeeef 
lGood
4.0 of 5 stars363 Reviews
v4.6 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 11 mins )
Show Prices
4.3 Excellent Based on 409 Reviews
$$$$$ Show Prices
Southampton Inn

Southampton Inn

91 Hill Street, Southampton (Map)
- (888) 420-1676 (888) 420-1676
eee 
lExcellent
3.5 of 5 stars372 Reviews
v10.9 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 26 mins )
Show Prices
4.3 Excellent Based on 373 Reviews
$$$$$ Show Prices
American Beech Hotel

American Beech Hotel

300 Main Street, Greenport (Map)
- (888) 420-1643 (888) 420-1643
eeef 
lExcellent
v9.6 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 70 mins )
Show Prices
4.8 Exceptional Based on 71 Reviews
$$$$$ Show Prices
The Roundtree Amagansett

The Roundtree Amagansett

Our Pick: Top Rated
273 Main Street Po Box 799, Amagansett (Map)
- (888) 420-1657 (888) 420-1657
eeeef 
lExceptional
4.5 of 5 stars124 Reviews
v9.9 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 22 mins )
Show Prices
4.0 Very Good Based on 234 Reviews
$$$$$ Show Prices
Journey East Hampton

Journey East Hampton

490 Pantigo Road, East Hampton (Map)
- (888) 420-1647 (888) 420-1647
eeee 
lVery Good
4.5 of 5 stars233 Reviews
v8.5 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 18 mins )
Show Prices
4.2 Very Good Based on 390 Reviews
$$$$$ Show Prices
East Hampton House Resort

East Hampton House Resort

226 Pantiago Road, East Hampton (Map)
- (888) 420-1655 (888) 420-1655
eee 
lVery Good
4.0 of 5 stars136 Reviews
v8.2 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 16 mins )
Show Prices
4.8 Exceptional Based on 30 Reviews
$$$$$ Show Prices
Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast

Arbor View House Bed and Breakfast

8900 Main Road, East Marion (Map)
- (888) 428-0221 (888) 428-0221
eeef 
lExceptional
4.0 of 5 stars223 Reviews
v12.1 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 76 mins )
Show Prices
4.2 Very Good Based on 105 Reviews
$$$$$ Show Prices
Mill House Inn

Mill House Inn

31 North Main Street, East Hampton (Map)
- (888) 420-1654 (888) 420-1654
eeeee 
lVery Good
4.0 of 5 stars136 Reviews
v7.4 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 16 mins )
Show Prices
3.9 Good Based on 94 Reviews
$$$$$ Show Prices
The Huntting Inn

The Huntting Inn

94 Main Street, East Hampton (Map)
- (888) 420-1642 (888) 420-1642
eeef 
lGood
4.0 of 5 stars136 Reviews
v7.1 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 15 mins )
Show Prices
Previous Next
1-12 of 28 Hotels near Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Frequently Asked Questions about hotels near Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor

Q

What hotels near Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor are close to restaurants?

If you're looking for Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor hotels that are close to the best restaurants, be sure to check these hotels out:

The Menhaden Hotel

Traveler Rating : Wonderful, 4.7
9.3 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 68 mins by car )

American Beech Hotel

Traveler Rating : Excellent, 4.3
9.6 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 70 mins by car )

Mill House Inn

Traveler Rating : Very Good, 4.2
7.4 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 16 mins by car )

Q

What are the best budget hotels near Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor in Sag Harbor?

Some of our top rated budget hotels near Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor are:

Hamlet Inn

Traveler Rating : Very Good, 4.0
14.8 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 28 mins by car )

Ocean View Terrace

Traveler Rating : Wonderful, 4.5
17.1 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 35 mins by car )

Ocean Vista Resort

Traveler Rating : Excellent, 4.3
16.0 miles from Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor ( 29 mins by car )

Q

Do you offer group hotel rates near Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor on ConcertHotels.com?

If you're booking 10+ rooms, get Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor Group Hotel Rates in seconds.

Select 10+ rooms in our search box at the top this page.

Hit the Search button.

Fill in your details and get competing quotes quickly as hotels bid to get your business.

Group Booking Questions? Call Us Now on (855)329-0862

-- Unrated

Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor Reviews

Many have visited, but none have returned to tell the tale. Will you be the first to write a review of Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor?

Write a review

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

Bay Street Theater & Sag Harbor Center for the Arts is #1 of 23 things to do in Sag Harbor

5 of 5 stars5 out of 5
By: rlee2000, East Northport, New York
Mon 29 Jul, 2024
l My wife, son, and sister-in-law went to see comedian Mike Birbiglia on Sunday afternoon at the Bay Street theatre and had a great experience. His performance was excellent, the theater has no bad...

Read Full Review
5 of 5 stars5 out of 5
By: John F, Setauket, New York
Sun 26 Nov, 2023
l This the second time we have gone to this theater. It will not be the last. Performances rival those in the city. The presentation of Arthur Miller's "The Crucible" was as powerful as any I have seen...

Read Full Review
4 of 5 stars4 out of 5
By: jerrykT4394JA
Fri 19 Aug, 2022
l Great performance of Ragtime. Unfortunately the theater management is Covid-paranoid, still requiring masks!

Read Full Review
Read All Reviews | Write a Review | ©TripAdvisor 2024
Write a Review of Bay Street Theater Sag Harbor
© ConcertHotels.com all rights reserved