Menu

Brewster’s New Buffalo

Brewster’s New Buffalo, 11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo
|
4.8
RESTAURANT RATING: 
EXCEPTIONAL
4.8 out of 5 (263 Ratings)
Powered By Opentable
About Brewster’s New Buffalo
Average Price
$30 and under
Cuisine
Italian
Opening Hours
Daily 9:00 am-10:00 pm

Brewster’s New Buffalo Customer Reviews

Many have visited, but none have returned to tell the tale. Will you be the first to write a review of Brewster’s New Buffalo?

Write a review

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

Brewster's New Buffalo is #3 of 33 things to do in New Buffalo

2 of 5 stars2 out of 5
By: bhpatrick4, Indiana
Fri 17 Jan, 2025
l Dinner menu is limited. I like fish but didn’t feel good about a $35 dinner but my family insisted so I ordered the halibut dinner. So disappointed! Served in a bowl with some white sauce, loaded...

Read Full Review
5 of 5 stars5 out of 5
By: Climber07939379204
Mon 16 Sep, 2024
l This is our favorite restaurant to go to every time we stay at the Four w ends Casino! We always say we will try something different and then we don't. Brewster's is the best!

Read Full Review
4 of 5 stars4 out of 5
By: Richard C
Sun 18 Aug, 2024
l The food was great. The management the opposite. Their bruschetta was amazing. Exactly the right level of red onions & a very good balsamic. Cacio d pepe exactly authentic, chicken alfredo the same...

Read Full Review
Read All Reviews | Write a Review | ©TripAdvisor 2025
Write a Review of Brewster’s New Buffalo
Reference (Required)
Your Name (Required)
Your City
Your Email Address (Required)
Your overall rating of the restaurant
What was good?
What was bad?
Your review
Brewster’s New Buffalo 11 W Merchant St, New Buffalo
Tap the image to hear the thrill for yourself! Thrill Seeker by Merry Muntjac
Reserve Online
© ConcertHotels.com all rights reserved