Very good

Liked: Excellent location and great services.
Disliked: HVAC systems hood has loud noise. Recommend to bring the earplugs

Very good

Liked: Spacious and the vintage lookFelt like home away from home
Disliked: The bath tub the water wasn't going out while showering and when I got back at 2am and ringing the bell the desk clerk wasn't answering until I called the hotel while I stood in the cold waiting for her to open the door

Exceptional

Excellent, looking forward to coming...

Liked: Excellent stay and a highly recommended place. Stuff is very kind and accommodated a request for an upgrade from single to double room. Rooms are very comfortable and clean.
Disliked: Loud music during the night from the streets

Peaceful place - great location

Liked: Great location. It's near several subway stations and ferry stop. Rooms are spacious, and clean, but dark (rather common thing in Manhattan). Infrastructure could use a refreshment though. Staff at the reception wasn't super welcoming when we arrived, but people sitting there on subsequent days were nice. The fact that coffee and tea is available the whole day, as well as sweet snacks, is a nice touch.
Disliked: Breakfast is modest. A little renovation would be nice. No other reservations :)

Very good

Liked: Breakfast not incredible, but good.

Exceptional

Bad stay

Liked: The position.
Disliked: Very old and also dirty. The moquette, the curtains and the chairs have stains. The breakfast is ridiculous, no express beverages, pastries are packaged snacks.

Very comfortable would recommend it.

Liked: Spacious room clean and staff friendly and helpful.
Disliked: Nothing.