Exceptional

Liked: There wasn't any breakfast

Pros and cons

Liked: I love the location, and the staff were great!
Disliked: The room was unclean, my daughter found a half eaten mini egg. It was a cold and windy night, and we had no thermostat and were cold.

Cozy, warm, quiet.

Liked: We arrived late because we missed the ferry. My friend really wanted 2 beds which they easily accommodated with a smile.
Disliked: It was quiet, we had a great nights sleep which we really needed.

Very good

Rustic charm with great sunsets

Liked: Homey and comfy, great sunsets. Love the locally made soap - such a nice touch! Pub downstairs was fun with good food.

We really enjoyed our visit...

Liked: We liked the dining room and the pub and appreciate having them right where we are staying. I enjoy having a great meal and drinks and not having to worry about driving. The sea view from both the pub and the dining room is fantastic. The jalapeno poppers were great.Really loved the building construction from logs and stone.Our king sized bed in room 9 was very comfortable. The room itself was strange with the different levels on the window side of the room. I've never seen anything like that before but it did work well for storage of our luggage etc. Very nice to have the fridge and coffee maker in our room.
Disliked: When we come back again, I think I would take a room or cabin with a patio rather than focusing on the king size bed. The bathroom in room 9 is quite small. The room is very dark at night so I would bring a night light next time.

Good

Liked: The accommodation is older and not fancy but is clean. The lodge pub had excellent burgers, the staff were great, and the location is excellent, right across from sunset beach!
Disliked: The cabin was near the pub parking lot.

Excellent stay. Great location. Gabriola...

Liked: Beautiful location. Excellent view of the ocean. Eagles right outside our window.
Disliked: There was a bit of tv noise from the next room.

Great find on Galiano island

Liked: Everything the room was rustic and so full of character the pub was fun it was st Patrick's day, the food in the main restaurant was the best I've ever had in a hotel setting on the west coast
Disliked: Only one thing, the restaurant, wasn't open for breakfast