The Melville Inn by Innkeeper's Collection Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Joanne Mon, 21 April 2025
Lovely hotel with great staff
Liked: Close by to lots of things , the pub next door was lovely too also with lovely knowledgeable staff who couldn’t do enough for you.
Disliked: We didn’t have an openable window in our room
Luis Mon, 21 April 2025
Don't use it ever again
Liked: We did like the cleaning in general
Disliked: Well,!!! Wi-Fi has a poor signal,in terms of staff at the reception was like an obligation every time we ask a question,we stayed 4 nights in these days if you don't say good morning or a simple Hi they don't even care,our checkout the lady at reception didn't mention or ask how was our stay or perhaps asking if we did enjoy.WE WILL NEVER COME BACK
Maggie Mon, 21 April 2025
Very good
Liked: Friendly, warm, welcoming hotel with great restaurant.
Disliked: Sunday morning breakfast not available until 8am when we needed to leave by 8am - paid for but not able to use which definitely week wasn’t pleasing.
Andrew Mon, 21 April 2025
Lovely hotel, friendly and helpful...
Liked: Did not have a breakfast.
Disliked: Not much to be honest, it is what it is.
Emma Mon, 21 April 2025
Would definitely recommend
Liked: Clean and friendly
Chris Mon, 21 April 2025
Excellent
Liked: Nice rooms, friendly staff, good food including breakfast in the pub next door.Free car park and bus to Edinburgh stops outdoors
Disliked: Three points which would make this hotel 100% perfectExtra chair in bedroom as only one at momentKing Sized bedWindow that opens
Derek Sun, 20 April 2025
Good location and rooms, ruined...
Liked: Room decor and bar next door. Easy to park
Disliked: Wi-Fi awful and bombarded with emails as part of troublefree check in. When responded to one of the multiple messages, was told by the system, that they already had those details. Then asked to write (ink) same details on arrival until I challenged why. Only soft pillows in room.
Westgate Sun, 20 April 2025
Superb
Liked: Large room size Great food Very good valueClose to main routes
Disliked: Sofa bed less comfy for an adult but great for kids
Shaz Sat, 19 April 2025
Exceptional
Marius Sat, 19 April 2025
Superb
Liked: The restaurant was a step away. Near Edinburgh castle, national museum and other places ( 15 min drive).
Disliked: Couldn't open the window for fresh air.