Exceptional

Liked: Conveniently located in the west village and has a luxe old charm . The staff is super helpful
Disliked: Nothing

Exceptional

Great Hotel in NYC

Liked: This is our go to place in NYC. Great location. Rooms are a little cramped, but we love the proximity to the subway and great restaurants.
Disliked: Like I said, rooms are a little on the small side, but that is expected in NYC. Hotels have become more expensive since the AirBNB restrictions. Other than that, we love The Marlton.

Would recommend for a single...

Liked: Good location. Cool decor.
Disliked: Room size is unbelievably small - like a bed only - and suitcase under the bed. BUT it didn’t really matter as we were out for most the days. Would be great for a solo traveler!!

A charming delightful return to...

Liked: An earlier era’s charm well preserved and honored. Warmth of the overall environment including welcoming, pleasant and professional staff in all quarters.
Disliked: We don’t mind the small, but quaint well-appointed and comforts, but having to open and access luggage on the floor??? Not convenient especially as we get older.

Superb

Liked: Best location! Great security measures! Beautiful room! Staff were all extremely friendly!
Disliked: Had frittata as part of complimentary breakfast which was dry/overcooked and lacked flavor.

Nice value and great staff.

Liked: Nice lobby and charming rooms (but small). Staff is first rate and very accommodating. Breakfast is fantastic.
Disliked: Rooms were small, some had little natural light.

Exceptional

Good

Disliked: Rooms were a little too tiny for me