Superb

Liked: Really nice location and great decoration
Disliked: Breakfast was really basic

A place I would stay...

Liked: Super friendly staff and ideally located
Disliked: It would have been nice to have a bar of its own rather than next door but bit a big deal

Superb location , lovely elegant...

Liked: Superb location . Having stayed midtown just before it was fabulous to come to a calmer elegant location . Staff couldn’t be better . Attended immediately to any request . Will return
Disliked: No complaints

Great location, welcoming feel, good...

Liked: The lobby area is very attractive and feels welcoming and the room was a good size and comfortable. The fitness room, while compact, had a good selection of machines and weights and the continental breakfast being included was nice. Overall I enjoyed my stay and would be happy to return on another visit.
Disliked: Small thing - but the corridor that the fitness room is on is a bit smelly - think it's because doors to the outside were left open and there must be trash there, so would be great to keep those doors closed to avoid the smell. This didn't negatively affect my stay, but hopefully a useful piece of feedback.

Overall, we were pleased with...

Liked: Thought the lobby was charming. Room was clean and comfortable
Disliked: We did not like the bed

Good

Liked: Breakfast. Staff very friendly with my dog.
Disliked: Rooms a bit run down

Was ok but not wonderful

Liked: Clean, located well , lobby cozy
Disliked: Small room, very expensive, breakfast mediocer,

This is the bomb (...

Liked: This is a great hotel. Quirky boat theme design to all rooms which are not massive but very comfortable. Robes, well stocked room fridge and bar, breakfast included and a great restaurant on site. Staff are simple excellent . Helpful with information and late checkout.
Disliked: Manhattan prices !

Superb

Liked: Beautiful historic property, nicely updated. Did not seem ada accessible though. Across the street from Chelsea market.