Clean, well maintained, great location...

Liked: Classic historical building, very friendly staff, superb breakfast

Very restful, wonderful 3 day...

Liked: Bay View is a beautiful hotel. Everything is top quality. The staff were exceptional, from the moment we walked in the door. Our breakfast was delicious, the view was outstanding and the staff went above & beyond to make sure we were well taken care of.
Disliked: Unfortunately, because of the season right after Christmas, the restaurant was not serving meals. We did have a beautiful breakfast each day, but no other meals in the hotel. However we found some great places in Petoskey to have other meals.

Superb

Liked: It was a pleasant surprise to have the breakfast included.
Disliked: I cannot think of one thing

Lovely historic Inn with friendly...

Liked: Very nice . Good service. $25 per person credit for breakfast Happy hour drink credits
Disliked: Scary old elevator !

Exceptional

Liked: Everything was very clean, the breakfast was amazing

Exceptional staff, lovely property

Liked: Historic, lovely views, close to town, nice outdoor spaces

Short stay, great experience!

Liked: The historical hotel is on the shore of traverse bay - it's a perfect spot with limitless views for miles around the lake

A Top Vintage Hotel Choice

Liked: Excellent hotel room and dining.
Disliked: The water was lukewarm when showering.

Superb

Liked: The Sunday Buffet
Disliked: Nothing. It was perfect.