Very good

Overpriced with basic facilities

Liked: Good location in Midtown New York, close to Grand Central station. Staff are friendly and happy to assist with any queries checking in. Room is large with ensuite bathroom.
Disliked: For the amount it cost to say there ($600+ per night), the value for money was terrible. The room is whitewashed concrete, so despite being large, it had no character and felt very soulless. My room also wasn't cleaned during my 2 night stay, and there was no breakfast or food service available in the hotel. There is a british pub below where you can buy lunch & dinner.

Fabulous

Liked: I traveled for medical reasons the staff could not have done more for me whilst I stayed with them, they were beyond kind

Very central, comfortable stay- would...

Liked: Great location in East Midtown, close to great bars and eateries and a few minutes walk to the subway/bus. Surprisingly quite due to location of room away from the busy streets of NYC.
Disliked: It’s accessed via a very cool select entertaining venue, which meant at times the steps to the building were difficult to access and doormen operated. This was only an occasional issue but did make it difficult to get in or out at times. Definitely would not stop me from staying again.

Excellent, historic and efficient hotel...

Liked: As an old social club, the building is beautiful, and it's amazing to have a speakeasy with multiple rooms downstairs. Very friendly workers who will get you whatever you need. The room was comfy with lots of light.
Disliked: The hallways and elevator, in the dead of summer, could use some sort of air whether a conditioner or fan. Not a dealbreaker, but sometimes waiting for the elevator can get very hot. But that was my only gripe!

Superb

Superb

Exceptional

Exceptional