Excellent

Liked: As always our stay was quiet and comfortable and pleasant!

Lovely accommodations and friendly helpful...

Excellent location, lovely proprietor, and...

Liked: Convenient location, private cottage, well maintained
Disliked: Had a small snafu with heat in one of the bedrooms (didn’t realize the space heater depended on the light switch!), tight quarters for our family - but would rent a larger cottage next time

Superb

A wonderful, low-key place to...

Liked: The Phoenicia Lodge is a wonderful throwback evoking the "classic" Catskills experience. It was our first time staying, but will definitely not be the last! Our host, Sandra, was gracious and responsive. The cabin we stayed in was cozy, but exceptionally clean, tidy and warm. It's a great place to stay if you're in the area for skiing (as we were), hiking, or browsing. Belleayre Mountain is 15 minutes up the road, and the town of Phoenicia (less than 1/2 mile away) has nice options for breakfast and dining - Bettina's, The Phoenician Steakhouse, the Phoenicia Diner are all right there. Lovely!
Disliked: We had no complaints about our stay or the lodging.

Superb

Very good

Good

Liked: Location
Disliked: Old facilities for the price

Very good