I enjoyed my stay and...

Liked: Good choice of breakfast and nicely presented.Food, including the evening meal, was very good overall.I had a room with a lovely outlook across the loch.Good, quiet, country location.I liked the way the public rooms were decorated.Pleasant staff.
Disliked: My bathroom felt rather cramped, but it was nice and clean, which is much more important.

Very pleasant. Would do it...

Liked: Great food, but portions are too large, a bit of a waste of food.Location is fantastic for access to sites and views.
Disliked: Room could be a bit bigger. Need more accessible wall plugs.

Could be excellent

Liked: Wonderful location with great staff.
Disliked: Some rooms overlook bins; food not great; decor very 1980s.

Charming old world service, with...

Liked: The breakfast experience was faultless.The evening dining was absolutely superb, I stayed four nights and the specials in particular changed each day.The views are breathtaking.Also it was well situated as a starting point for sight-seeing around the island.
Disliked: If I had to nitpick then the rooms storage space and horizontal surfaces were limited especially in the bathroom, but workable.

Exceptional

Liked: I appreciated the extras … like a staff member suggesting they prepare a box lunch for us b/c we were leaving early to catch the 6 am ferry. The lunch was generous and sustained us until dinner!

Lovely location.

Liked: The staff were lovely and the food was good.
Disliked: We booked a small double room. The room was fine but the ensuite toilet and shower were tiny, so much so that you struggled to dry after your shower with the door shut!!!

exellent food tidy clean rooms...

Liked: good choice of local produce well cooked
Disliked: two keys to lock room doors bit old fashioned

Superb

Beautiful stay on Orkney

Liked: Perfect rural location to explore Orkney!