Location, staff and entertainment top...

Liked: Loved this place! The owner and staff went above and beyond to make you feel welcome. The entertainment options were amazing and we saw the Randy Roberts show as well as the singer in the lounge- both amazing. Loved the bar and the location was perfect for us at the quieter end of Duval St. The breakfast was excellent with 4 options to choose from.
Disliked: We wish there was an earlier option for morning coffee other than waiting for the restaurant to open at 8:30 am. A 24 hour keurig station for guest use would be perfect. The same for water. We ended up walking down to the Circle K and buying 2 gallons of water for our stay and keeping in our room fridge. (Although the staff was more than happy to refill our yeti tumblers when we needed). We also never used the pool even though our room was right next to it. The restaurant was packed nearly every day for breakfast, lunch and dinner and being that it overlooks the pool- we were self conscious swimming while people were eating. That said, we loved our stay and would come back again based on the wonderful staff and location. Thanks Christopher for a wonderful week

Exceptional

Recommend for a taste of...

Liked: Very nice historical place; classy feel; decorated nicely; beds comfortable; good bar and restaurant with good food choices
Disliked: Some uneven flooring near pool

Passable

Fabulous accommodation in a fantastic...

Liked: The staff were super friendly and the accommodation was quirky and fantastic. Location was excellent and the Randy Roberts show was immense. Would definitely recommend to others and if back in Key West would stay here again. The warmest welcome ever.
Disliked: Shower not quite powerful enough but not enough to put us off staying again.

Fantastic experience in Key West

Liked: Beautiful surroundings
Disliked: Amazing staff, extremely helpful

Very good

Liked: Tasty…variety of offerings

My stay was excellent. The...

Liked: Beautiful surroundings,clean & the pillows on the bed felt like heaven,also the breakfast was excellent.
Disliked: I liked everything about the property. The only issue I had was that a gratuity was asked to be given for each quest ,written at the bottom of the menu for breakfast, the breakfast was included in the cost of the stay,which wasn’t cheap. I believe, leaving a tip is up to the discretion of the individual, especially when paying for a room, which includes breakfast.

Exceptional