Beautiful resort and setting, but...

Liked: The rooms are sizeable, design-oriented and the location is charming. The farmhouse was beautiful and generally all the buildings were beautifully designed.Restaurant was good, prices not terrible for the quality,
Disliked: The service was truly lacking for the nightly price point. On check in, no one told us what amenities there were, where they were, etc. There is zero signage around the property directing you on where to go or highlighting what's there to explore. The staff is apathetic and quiet and not particularly interested in helping or going above and beyond. There's a self-serve bar in the farmhouse but it only had canned wine (which is not typically good) and had hardly anything left to mix with.There are firepits and fireplaces around but the staff wouldn't provide smores kits outside of restaurant hours (the restaurant closed at 9 and the smores kits are in the restaurant so you're out of luck if you want to do that after dinner). If they were in your room with a small map or list of amenities, at least you could make do on your own and have more to do. For the price we were surprised it was so barebones and DIY, you're on your own to figure out where everything is and what closes when etc.

Exceptional

Exceptional

Very good

Overhyped, social media marketing/influencer driven...

Liked: generally good views and good quality food at the restaurant
Disliked: The experience was far below expectations, including:-the presence of numerous family pets in dining areas that are clearly family pets and not service animals-a loud and disruptive New Years Eve day and evening experience - primarily loud and unindent supervised young children, including being able to hear them throughout the Farmhouse while in our room and during the entire course of our dinner. I’ve got 2 young kids myself so I have a bit of experience on both side of this. -a New Years Eve party with no bathroom attendant, individuals clear sneaking in the back door near the unattended bathroom shed to get around check in at the door -and finally, the situation with the bed in our room, which is clearly dangerous. Furthermore, I couldn’t help but notice from the open doors of other rooms being cleaned, that our room differed significantly in terms of size and appointments, including the bed frame. Overall, this was simply not a $1,600 for 2 nights type of experience in terms of ambiance or service.

discreet luxury hotel. Will definitely...

Liked: Comfortable rooms with a lot of privacy. Cozy beds, incredible robes and towels. The Aesop products in the room smell amazing. Rooms stocked with tea, coffee press and snacks.
Disliked: As a return visitor, I enjoyed the staff at the front desk and the waiters in the restaurant are kind and accommodating to needs. We wished that room service was an option. Also not enough water available in the room. The check in is too late (4 pm) and while we got into our room at 3 pm it would be nice is this was the standard. Felt a bit rushed with the 11 am checkout (with one particular woman at the front desk) considering the breakfast at the restaurant serves til 11 am and was quite busy. 12 pm would be an ideal time for checkout given the layout of the property. Room was a bit hot even set to 66 degrees.

Good

Liked: Excellent location for us. Breakfast was great, Room was perfect.
Disliked: We didn't like having to use the Jeep truck for moving around the resort. Paths were muddy and not easy to navigate to walk to our car

They need to just add...

Liked: The concept and style. Food was very good at dinner not so at breakfast .
Disliked: No personal amenities given such as cotton wool/ buds - not a box of tissues which is very odd for a hotel

Superb