Lovely

Liked: Location, silence, very clean, very good size of both bathroom and bedroom
Disliked: Nothing

Superb

Liked: Amazing location, right under the castle and in the old town of Tubingen. The staff were friendly and efficient, the rooms were comfortable and a good size. Breakfast was amazing, a really great selection of food and good coffee.

Exceptional

Had a wonderful time!

Liked: Great location, outstanding restaurant. Staff was exceptional
Disliked: No elevator

Exceptional

Justifiably popular

Liked: A few months ago I had to cancel a reservation here due to an emergency at home. The hotel refunded my money, though it didn't have to according to Booking's terms. I felt I owed it to them to make the journey when I could! Plus, I still wanted to visit Tubingen. So here I am reviewing them after finally getting there....The hotel is in a great location next to the castle but also not far from the station. We arrived very early, but as I'd asked to leave luggage due to our early arrival we actually found our room ready for check-in, two hours early. The staff are very kind and friendly, and we wished we could have stayed longer to try everything on the breakfast menu! We also had dinner in the restaurant and here were loads of excellent regional choices, including veggie and vegan. It was super-quiet at night, despite being so central.
Disliked: Another reviewer mentioned a smell of smoke in their room - I noticed this too, and suspect it's because I chose a cheaper room since we were only staying one night - I thought it would be a smaller room, but I think it more likely it was one not so recently decorated, so the smoke smell from before the ban lingered a bit in the building's fabric. The room was otherwise very clean, there were clear signs banning smoking, and the lower rooms looked recently redecorated.

Superb

Very good

Liked: The hotel is in a great location in the middle of the city centre but accessible by car. Staff is really friendly and helpful. Also, a charging station was directly at the hotel available. Unfortunately, I had only one night in Tübingen and hence could not explore much.
Disliked: The entrance to my room in a sperate building was a bit tricky. You open the door of the room and immediately there are three steps down. If you are not careful or attentive you could virtually fall into the room. A small warning sign could help. It was not a problem for me, but I could imagine.

We loved it and will...

Liked: Very comfortable room with nice views over the castle approach. Breakfast generous and our two dinners exceptional. The staff were very friendly and helpful.
Disliked: Nothing.