Homewood Suites By Hilton Carle Place - Garden City NY Guest Reviews
Write a review
0.7 miles from Carle Place centre |
Write a review
Qingjing Tue, 4 March 2025
Disappointing
Liked: Breakfast really bad
Disliked: Air conditioner too loud
Fortune Tue, 4 March 2025
Very good
Angela Tue, 4 March 2025
Pleasant
Liked: Quiet area and close to many things to do and places to eat.
Disliked: Outdated/broken furniture and appliances in the rooms. Dresser cabinets in the rooms were broken. Kitchen sink only put out boiling hot water. Our neatly put away garbage was kicked all over the hallway overnight by someone and I had to clean it up in the morning. The next night we had a drunk person sleeping by our door which made me feel unsafe as I was traveling with my 2 year old. Overall was an okay stay if needed to be in that location.
Walters Sat, 1 March 2025
Had a well rested stay.
Liked: Everything
Disliked: Nothing
Shelbbie Mon, 24 February 2025
Good
Amy Sun, 23 February 2025
Short, we were there for...
Liked: It was roomy and clean
Disliked: It was very beat up. The tub’s drain was no longer attached. The beds had these metal pieces sticking out. The vanity outside the bathroom was very beaten up, the wall was missing a piece of the molding. Definitely needed some repair. The coach could also use some pillows.
Alethea Thu, 20 February 2025
Stay FAR away from this...
Liked: Bed wasn’t bad
Disliked: I booked the hotel because I read that it was recently renovated. I don’t know if I got a suite that was missed or renovations are still in the works, but my room was in disrepair to say the least. There was water damage on the ceilings (paint peeling), the cabinets were unclean and falling apart. Hair in the bathtub. There was ONE set of silverware for a two bedroom suite. We had to pay for parking which is crazy. But that wasn’t even the worst of it: we had no hot water the morning after we arrived and there was zero communication about the issue (our room phone didn’t work so I had to call from my cell phone). When I asked them to call me back to tell me when the water issue was fixed, I was met with confusion. We ended up having to get our money back and go to another hotel. I would never stay here again.
Helen Mon, 17 February 2025
Very good
Jean Sat, 15 February 2025
It was acceptable-the rooms fine,felt...
Liked: The breakfast was not good.
Disliked: It was not fresh,not tasty.
Vanessa Wed, 12 February 2025
Ok for what we needed...
Liked: Room ready and clean when we arrived. Breakfast bagels lovely and fresh
Disliked: Room not cleaned great during stay shower gel tissues not replaced for a few days when empty. Parking was free on confirmation and there hotel directory services but wanted to charge us. (New thing brought in a few weeks ago we were told) I said they should honour our booking as was free when booked told to speak to manager than general manager