Gurney's Montauk Resort & Seawater Spa Guest Reviews
Write a review
2.7 miles from Montauk centre |
Write a review
Peter Sat, 23 November 2024
Pleasant
Liked: The staff are great. Rooms are very clean.
Disliked: You can't go from your room to restaurant, spa,outdoor pool or indoor pool without going outside. Whilst this may be no issue in the summer at this time of year it was cold outside. Went to indoor pool, has to go there dressed, change to swimsuit, and change back at indoor pool. When I was returning it had started raining. Front desk gave me an umbrella (also supplied to each room). I have a walking disability but had zero accommodation. To go to the restaurant I has to walk a distance downstairs. On the way back I had to trek upstairs. Parking forced me to trek upstairs after I parked. Very steep hills to negotiate. VERY steep hills.I was in a 600 number room. You have to do stairs. Place is not handicapped friendly. If you have walking issues do not stay here. Restaurant is way overpriced. I had the haddock and the portion was barely enough to make a sandwich. Wine was terribly over priced. Didnt order a side as they said it included fingerling potatoes. I got 3 potatoes about as big as my thumb. That's compared to Manhattan prices. They gave you a bottle of Prosecco in your room that was horrible. Only good if you have no taste buds and only want to get drunk. If they spent $5 more it could have been decent. I would have appreciated if they didn't give me that bottle.I went to bar by fireplace. Bartender had to look up recipe for Manhattan. It was half a drink. Maybe 4 shots of liquor. Charged me $22. I ordered the same from a waiter and it cost $20 for 3 times the drink.I wouldn't stay there again unless,They have nore accommodation for handicapped.They gave decent portions in the restaurants.They standardized they drink prices.Not a good experience.
Lauren Tue, 5 November 2024
Exceptional
Brendan Mon, 21 October 2024
Exceptional
Peter Fri, 11 October 2024
The experience couldn’t have been...
Liked: The room was spectacular with an unbelievable view of the ocean.
Simon Mon, 9 September 2024
Shambloic
Liked: Location
Disliked: Shambolic from start to finish. Check in was a joke. Hotel staff seemed to move around talk to each other as opposed to serving and little sign of any management whatsoever.
Donna Fri, 23 August 2024
Gurney's. For a guaranteed excellent...
Liked: Ocean location is unmatched. Staff is gracious.
Disliked: prices are so high. Would also appreciate shuttle from jitney dropoff.
John Sun, 18 August 2024
Good
Lior Sat, 10 August 2024
Exceptional
Safa Wed, 24 July 2024
Very good
John Sun, 21 July 2024
Use to be my summer...
Liked: Beach
Disliked: Gurneys front staff thinks that they’re doing you a favor by being there. Bad attitude. Much better in past years.