Full recommended

Liked: Very close to fifth avenue and Centralpark

Very nice. Welcoming. Excellent restaurant.

Liked: All logistics.
Disliked: Rooms on lower floors a little dark.

Our stay was very nice...

Liked: The property is very European and cozy. Desk staff and all employees are friendly and accommodating. Beds are very comfortable. I always request a walk in shower (rather than a shower/bath) as I use a cane for mobility, and the hotel always accommodates me.
Disliked: The room was very chilly, and it appeared the thermostat was broken. Closet light was burned out (it is supposed to light when closet door is opened), and one bedside light was burned out. I think light fixtures should be checked daily by housekeeping. Housekeeping could be stepped up. They forgot to remove trash and vacuum one day.

Very good

Very good

Liked: Location and room
Disliked: Breakfast is suboptimal.

Exceptional

Liked: Wow! What a deal! This rate among our best experiences in Europe. Wonderful

Exceptional

Great Location, Good Room, Good...

Liked: The room itself was lovely and big enough for a family of four. There was two lots of cupboard spaces so we could put away suitcases. There was a little room near the door with a fridge and a sink. The bedroom was really nice with a king bed and the windows could open so you could hear the New York sounds. The sofa couch was quite comfortable too. It was close to the subway and Central station. The staff were really lovely and the housekeepers were always around if you needed anything.
Disliked: There definitely could have been a microwave in the kitchenette area and the room doesn't have smart TVs, so you couldn't stream any services which was a bit disappointing. Also, the only bathroom is in the main room and there was no vent, so any smells just wafted straight into the bedroom.

Passable

Liked: location
Disliked: Very noisy room on the second floor. Poor noise insulation.