Very comfortable, lovely staff, I...

Liked: Great Location.

Gorgeous views but a little...

Liked: The location and views were amazing and all the start were so lovely.
Disliked: The heated towel rail didn’t work, so the bathroom was cold and the radiators were weirdly behind the curtains in the room, so the room was cold. Tried to go for a shower at 0615, but there was no hot water until 0730 in the morning, which was strange for a hotel. Of the 3 out of hours contact numbers, 2 didn’t work and 1 was a wrong number.

Short but fantastic

Liked: Breakfast was excellent and lovely location to enjoy

Superb

Liked: Great location, very friendly and helpful staff
Disliked: Had to leave early as my husband was unwell

Superb

Liked: Friendly staff and they loved our Dog, Nala.
Disliked: Pub closing early :-)

relaxing

Liked: Breakfast was lovely freshly cooked to order with fresh tea coffee juice

From edge of sanity to...

Liked: Last minute booking after getting lost in wind, rain and darkness trying to find our self-catering property! Glad (and very relieved) to have found the Edgcumbe Arms online as we sheltered in the car. Lovely building and location. Very friendly and helpful staff. Room cosy, stylish and well thought out. Bed very comfy for excellent sleep in quiet location. Shower amazing with two different heads to chose from. Kettle in room with several drinks options including bottled water and some biccies. TV, hairdryer, iron with ironing board, shower/hair stuff. Even vanity kit. Towels big enough to go round a curvy body! Good and varied options for brekkie. Car park at rear. Bus service nearby and foot ferry from beach. No disturbance from those though. Easy access to Plymouth via those if not wanting to drive. (We only used the ferry though.)
Disliked: It's not really a didn't like thing but it would have been nice to have had a selection of dinner choices rather than just fish and chips on Friday and for the bar to be open later. However, we understand why as, due to the time of year, it was very quiet in the evenings. It's probably a lot different at other times of year, especially due to it's waterside setting. Didn't spoil the experience though. Would return if in the area.

Looking forward to come back...

Liked: Perfect place - quiet and wonderful location - easy ferry ride to Plymouth just across the street - nice atmosphere in the pub - great ales and Plymouth gin :)
Disliked: The weather...

Friendly and delightful

Liked: Delightful old fashioned pub
Disliked: Expensive! Not sure they justify the price tag