Good

Liked: Stayed Feb 14th thru 18th. Attended Festival of the Dark Arts, location was perfect. Bed was comfy, shower was hot with excellent pressure.
Disliked: Wasn't exactly like pictures, was sharing with friend who was going to sleep on the couch which we thought was going to look like in pictures. When arrived it was barely even a love seat, more like metal frame with cushions. We asked front desk if they had a cot or something equivalent, but were told they do not. Nice front desk assoc gave us extra blankets & pillows.The coffee maker was electric kettle with instant coffee, not ideal. The light/ fan fixture above bed would turn on at super random times during the night.

Enjoyed the location and the...

Disliked: No signs or instructions on how to turn on the heat.

Good

What a gorgeous hotel!! Cozy,...

Liked: Absolutely loved the design! Such cozy vibes!!
Disliked: Loved everything

The Commodore Hotel will always...

Liked: Location was great! The charm of a 100 year old building was exceptional! The staff person was exceptional as well. The bathroom was incredible.
Disliked: A firmer mattress would have been great

Exceptional

Loud traffic noise into our...

Liked: The hotel, the staff, the age of the hotel, the remodeling and the size of our room were great. But
Disliked: The room was their largest and newly renovated delightfully. But, the traffic noise was overwhelming! I wish we would have known to pick a room as far away from the corner of two busy streets!

Superb

Not recommended for any privacy,...

Liked: Definitely not a good value for $. Too expensive for a tiny room with a bathroom down the hall. It was clean and in a great downtown location
Disliked: Tiny room, bathroom down the hall, one shower for all. Little things like a bathmat on the floor were missing. Make it comfortable