United States
Canada
United Kingdom
New Zealand
AustraliaCave Mountain Motel Guest Reviews
Overall Average Score:
Excellent (4.3 out of 5)
Write a review
Menu
| 1.9 miles from Windham centre |
Write a review
Nelson Mon, 10 March 2025
Stay was about what we...
Liked: breakfast was very limited, but the coffee was hot.
Disliked: Room air smelled a bit stale. Shower wasn't entirely clean. Walls seemed very thin.
Joanna Thu, 26 December 2024
Very good
Liked: Cute little motel nestled into the mountains of the Catskills!
Kenneth Tue, 29 October 2024
Poor
Liked: Did not take breakfast
Disliked: Room size
Allison Wed, 16 October 2024
Exceptional
Donna Tue, 15 October 2024
Clean, comfortable, welcoming. Great location!
Patti Sun, 13 October 2024
Excellent
Liked: Exceptional
Disliked: Nothing
Karola Wed, 28 August 2024
Superb
Liked: Close to Windham, NY. The room and bed was comfortable. The water pressure was good. Breakfast was great.
Disliked: Not anything that I can think of.
Beam Tue, 27 August 2024
Nice place that is priced...
Liked: Location was ideal for our needsNothing fancy, but perfectly acceptable
Disliked: Nothing
Francis Sat, 24 August 2024
shower was abnormally small, could...
Liked: Location was easy to find, but on a busy street and was rather noisy with traffic.
Disliked: S
Ellen Sun, 21 July 2024
It was disheartening in so...
Liked: A very homey place with lots of flowers. The rooms were sweet. Good assortment of continental breakfast food.
Disliked: Driving up to the motel, I first saw a large Trump flag waving from the flagpole. I'd always thought that business and politics don't mix. I entered the office, which was actually the front room of their house, and was blown away by the smell of cigarettes. I almost had an asthma attack on the spot. I made my way to my room through the cloud of pot smoke on the porch. The smell of mildew and cigarettes in my room was overwhelming- I had to use my inhaler just to breathe. The next morning we got an air filter, which helped some. Or maybe I got used to it.There was a nice breakfast nook with good coffee, juice, and cereal. Also, there was an array of Newsmax and Friends of Zion magazines. Whatever happened to Readers Digest and People magazines? Do we really need to be so polarizing first thing in the morning?
