Carfraemill Guest Reviews
Write a review
Write a review
Ed Mon, 14 April 2025
Very good
Keith Thu, 10 April 2025
For the price every thing...
Liked: Breakfast was excellent
Disliked: Nothing comes to mind
Sylvia Thu, 27 March 2025
Exceptional
Liked: The room was very clean and comfortable with a very good ensuite. The dinner was very good and, although breakfast was slightly haphazard , cooked items were very tasty. The hotel is a lovely base for local hillwalking.
Disliked: At breakfast there was no "breakfast bar" set out with choices of cereal, yogurt, fruit, juice etc but were available on request.
Mcclory Sun, 23 March 2025
Very good
Liked: Nice small hotel in great location for visiting the Scottish Border region. Accommodation was good and food very good. Staff deserve top marks
Disliked: None
Jordan Thu, 20 March 2025
The best food I’ve had...
Liked: The staff and food were absolutely amazing, the rooms were perfect and had everything you needed after being out all day.
Disliked: Parking wasn’t overly secure, but, was safe enough for the 2 nights we were there.
Stuart Mon, 17 March 2025
Good halfway stop for our...
Liked: Breakfast excellent, room comfortable albeit a bit dated . Staff very welcoming and location excellent for anyone travelling to Edinburgh or beyond as we were.
Disliked: Heating a bit hit and miss
Kylie Sat, 4 January 2025
Would definitely stay here again!
Liked: Loved the bedroom had tea and coffee and cookies, host, the breakfast was amazing got a lot food, teas, coffees and juices!! Such a cozy ambience especially with their fireplace on.
Disliked: Hot water took too long to heat up for a shower. The trucks/ cars were a little loud driving past on the main road which our room was near.
Natasha Thu, 26 December 2024
Exceptional
Liked: The staff were so welcoming, especially the manager, Paul, who was such a great host. Perfect short stay for our travels.
Suzie Tue, 10 December 2024
Really enjoyed it, would definitely...
Liked: The staff were exceptionally friendly and welcoming. Lovely location.
Mark Mon, 9 December 2024
Good
Liked: Staff were friendly and welcoming, couldn’t be more accommodating.Very good food, excellent portions. Lovely open fire and Christmas decorations. Room was comfortable and was good value for what we had paid. Would stay again
Disliked: Had heavy rain, had a bit of a leak through the ceiling. Some maintenance needed to tidy things up but was overall was clean.