Exceptional

How a stay should be.

Liked: Everything. A beautiful inn with a short to the centre and the best breakfast I have tasted for a long time. A wonderful host as well please don't change anything.
Disliked: Nothing apart from having to leave.

Period Charm. Delicious breakfast

Liked: What an interesting place to stay! Just out of the main part of town (which was great) but easy walking distance to everything. This historic house with its period style decor was quite a place. Lovely home cooked breakfast served in the dining room in the morning. The stairs were very creaky ( to be expected given the age of the house) but not a problem we were just conscious we didn't want to disturb other guests.

Be careful what you reserve....

Liked: Excellent breakfast
Disliked: No air conditioning

Nice place

Liked: very relaxed and some nice touches such as sweets and drinks and patio furniture
Disliked: could hear every creak and no choice at breakfast

Comfortable, quiet, and accesssible location....

Liked: Comfortable facility in close proximity to the town center. Parking was tight but at least we had parking.
Disliked: N/a

Very poor

Liked: We were really disappointed with our stay at 1899 Inn. We visited because of all the excellent reviews but it turns out that most the reviews are for the previous owners!I booked months ago and chose a particular room. When we arrived, we were given a different room with no explanation until I questioned the room ; only to be told they had double booked and given the room I chose to someone else. Not a great start. They did offer us a different room for 1 night but having to change rooms half way through our stay wasn't ideal.We travel a lot and have stayed at a lot of inns in the US. We have never come across such unwelcoming hosts before. We were given no information on the area , no recommendations on restaurants/ things to do at all. The only thing they told us was don't park in the street! The breakfast was truly awful, we couldn't eat any of it . It was 1 thing , just plonked down with no introduction so take it or leave it and they didn't ask us if we had any dietary requirements either.The location in Deadwood is great but the inn itself is very overpriced and underwhelming.

Superb

Liked: Hosts were awesome. Location was excellent. Bedding was comfy.
Disliked: A bit disappointed with breakfast only because it was offered as a full English but was not.

Will definitely stay again. Great...

Liked: Antiques, old west feel, safety. J’s breakfast was very tasty. Aaron’s recommendations were very helpful .
Disliked: Parking